How can you compare the tone of two poems?

• A. Identify the attitudes of the speakers, use language choices, imagery, and rhythm to illustrate tone; show similarities and differences
• B. Compare only the plot and setting
• C. Focus solely on punctuation
• D. Treat tone as the same in all poems

Answer: (A)

To compare tone, focus on the speakers’ attitudes toward the subject and show how language choices, imagery, and rhythm convey that attitude, then compare where these elements are similar or different in the two poems. Tone is the mood or stance the speaker takes, and you reveal it by looking at word choices (diction), the images the poems create, and the rhythm or pace of the lines. You can notice if the tone is harsh, reflective, ironic, joyful, or somber by noticing how these features work together.

This approach works best because it captures how the poems feel and what they imply, not just what happens on the surface. Focusing only on plot and setting misses the heart of tone since poetry often conveys mood through voice and stylistic choices rather than through narrative events. Looking only at punctuation is too narrow and can miss broader patterns in diction, imagery, and rhythm that establish tone. And assuming the tone is the same in both poems ignores the distinct voices and perspectives each poem has.